Let's start with yesterday:
A skimmer (we have a metal one), a plate lifter (as useless as it is to me, Mark has another one. The compromises we make...). Also, a carving fork. I found two more this morning. Mark needs to approve getting rid of one of the remaining two.
Today, I rummaged through the kitchen drawer again and found the following:
The bottle openers (and corkscrews, and can openers) that we wound up keeping served more than one function, and were easy-ish to store.
Yes, we were breaking the principle of having more than one item, but hopefully we will rid of more in the future. Baby steps!